Check out the new USENIX Web site. next up previous
Next: Asymmetric Multi-Process Event-Driven Up: Server Architectures Previous: Multi-threaded

Single-process event-driven

Figure 4: Single Process Event Driven - The SPED model uses a single process to perform all client processing and disk activity in an event-driven manner.

The single-process event-driven (SPED) architecture uses a single event-driven server process to perform concurrent processing of multiple HTTP requests. The server uses non-blocking systems calls to perform asynchronous I/O operations. An operation like the BSD UNIX select or the System V poll is used to check for I/O operations that have completed. Figure 4 depicts the SPED architecture.

A SPED server can be thought of as a state machine that performs one basic step associated with the serving of an HTTP request at a time, thus interleaving the processing steps associated with many HTTP requests. In each iteration, the server performs a select to check for completed I/O events (new connection arrivals, completed file operations, client sockets that have received data or have space in their send buffers.) When an I/O event is ready, it completes the corresponding basic step and initiates the next step associated with the HTTP request, if appropriate.

In principle, a SPED server is able to overlap the CPU, disk and network operations associated with the serving of many HTTP requests, in the context of a single process and a single thread of control. As a result, the overheads of context switching and thread synchronization in the MP and MT architectures are avoided. However, a problem associated with SPED servers is that many current operating systems do not provide suitable support for asynchronous disk operations.

In these operating systems, non-blocking read and write operations work as expected on network sockets and pipes, but may actually block when used on disk files. As a result, supposedly non-blocking read operations on files may still block the caller while disk I/O is in progress. Both operating systems used in our experiments exhibit this behavior (FreeBSD 2.2.6 and Solaris 2.6). To the best of our knowledge, the same is true for most versions of UNIX.

Many UNIX systems provide alternate APIs that implement true asynchronous disk I/O, but these APIs are generally not integrated with the select operation. This makes it difficult or impossible to simultaneously check for completion of network and disk I/O events in an efficient manner. Moreover, operations such as open and stat on file descriptors may still be blocking.

For these reasons, existing SPED servers do not use these special asynchronous disk interfaces. As a result, file read operations that do not hit in the file cache may cause the main server thread to block, causing some loss in concurrency and performance.

next up previous
Next: Asymmetric Multi-Process Event-Driven Up: Server Architectures Previous: Multi-threaded
Peter Druschel