Check out the new USENIX Web site. next up previous
Next: Concluding Remarks Up: A Modular and Extensible Infrastructure Previous: Performance Optimizations and Analysis

   
Related Work

There has been considerable work on improving performance of Java programs in uniprocessor environments [1,2,3,4]. For example, Alpern et al. describe the design and implementation of the Jalapeño virtual machine [1], which incorporates a number of novel optimizations in its JIT compiler. Artigas et al. [3] investigate compiler and run-time support for arrays in Java, and show that improvements can be attained by eliminating run-time checks. Much of this work is orthogonal to ours, in that it improves uniprocessor performance. However, such improvements carry over to multiprocessors, and we expect them to be easily integrated into the Jupiter framework.

There are a number of JVMs and JVM frameworks designed for research into JVM design. They include the Sun Microsystems JDK [8], Kaffe [9], the IBM Jalapeño JVM [1], Joeq [19], OpenJIT [20], and SableVM [7]. However, these frameworks often address flexibility in particular dimensions of JVM design, while in contrast, Jupiter's flexibility is intended to be pervasive and fine-grained, allowing straightforward modification of any aspect of the system. For example, OpenJIT is an object-oriented framework for experimenting with JIT compiler designs and is implemented as a JIT-compiler plug-in to Sun's JDK, making it limited to JIT compiler research. Similarly, while Jalapeño (recently released as the Jikes RVM [21]) was designed as ``flexible test bed where novel virtual machine ideas can be explored, measured, and evaluated''[1] in an industrial-grade server JVM, much of the work surrounding it explored JIT design. Though its object-oriented design undoubtedly possesses a large degree of inherent flexibility, it is unclear the extent to which the system is flexible in some aspects, such as object layout, stack layout, method dispatch, and so on.


next up previous
Next: Concluding Remarks Up: A Modular and Extensible Infrastructure Previous: Performance Optimizations and Analysis
Tarek S. Abdelrahman
2002-05-27