Check out the new USENIX Web site. next up previous
Next: PF-related Tags Up: Using mbuf_tags Previous: IPsec-related Tags

Loop-Detection Tags

  These tags are issued and consumed entirely by the bridge [7], gif interface, and gre interface subsystems respectively. Their main purpose is to detect processing cycles that would cause endless encapsulation or layer-2 packet forwarding. In all cases, the packet is dropped (in contrast to the IPsec loop-detection recovery, discussed in the previous section).

Systems without mbuf_tags have addressed the problem of loop detection/avoidance through ad-hoc and unsafe methods. In most cases, processing is assumed to be single-threaded; loops are detected through the use of locks or global variables. Not only is this approach is infeasible in multi-threaded and SMP kernels, it will also not work in certain configurations. For example, consider the case of two or more virtual bridges sharing two Ethernet interfaces: a packet scheduled for transmission in one interface of one bridge will be also scheduled for transmission on the other interface of the same bridge, also ``jumping'' to the second virtual bridge, whereupon it will be scheduled for transmission on the original Ethernet interface, whereupon the cycle will restart. The previous method cannot detect this failure, because bridge processing occurs at a software interrupt, making it impossible to keep packet state independently of the packet. Other similar cases arise then two or more of GRE, IP-in-IP, and bridging are combined in particular ways.

Furthermore, use of locks or global variables for detecting re-entry would make it difficult to implement some legitimate configurations, e.g., hierarchical bridges (whereby traffic propagated through one set of interfaces is also sent through a second set, but not vice versa). Admittedly, these uses are rather arcane and error-prone -- they are mentioned only as an example of the flexibility of using tags for loop detection.


next up previous
Next: PF-related Tags Up: Using mbuf_tags Previous: IPsec-related Tags
Angelos D. Keromytis
7/7/2003